|
| |
WSU FACULTY SENATE MEETING
March 26, 2001
Senators Present: Beckry Abdel-Magid, Sara Barbor, Matt Bosworth,
David Bratt, Marianna Byman, Narayan Debnath, Darrell Downs, Shirley Eiken, Ron Elcombe,
Mark Engen, Pat Ferden, Matthew Hyle, Colette Hyman, Mary Kesler (Sabbatical), Vernon
Leighton, Peter Miene, Bill Ng, Frances Ragsdale, Holly Shi, Dean Feller, Susanne Smith,
Jo Stejskal, Cathy Summa, Bruce Svingen, Paul Vance, Kerry Williams, Alex Yard.
Senators Absent:
Others Present: Kelly Herold.
Call to Order
Alex Yard called the meeting to order at 3:04 p.m.
Approval of Minutes of February 26, 2001.
B. Svingen/S. Smith moved to approve the Feb. 26 minutes as written.
Motion Carried.
Agenda Additions and Approval
1. COM-H: Social Committee
2. NB-H: Executive Committee Recommendation regarding LOU at SCSU
B. Ng/S. Sloan moved to approve these additions.
Motion Carried.
President's Report
1. Transfer issues were discussed at the recent Board meeting. IFO stance is that
the rules of transferring in of courses must be set by the local campus accepting (or not
accepting) the credits. CC/TC's are trying to make all their courses equivalent to State
Univ. courses. Senate apparently wants to have legislation on complete transferability,
but House was more on the IFO side.
2. Target of overall budget numbers has not been set yet.
3. Change of reciprocity rules so that it would be more difficult for outside state
students to attend MN schools. IFO is opposed to this.
4. During the Planning Committee meeting of the Sesquicentennial Celebration, Jerry
Pappenfuss seemed to need more understanding of what IFO faculty does! In general, we need
to do a better public-image job. Government Relations Committee will work on this issue.
Review of Meet and Confer Notes
March 19, 2001 notes included in packet.
Committees
- A2C2 (Com A, distributed at Senate Meeting)
A2C2 Chair Kelly Herold reported on the following and requested Faculty Senate
approval:
I. Course / Program Proposals
A. New/Revised Course Proposals
a. CHEM 360 - Chemical Information
b. SOCW 390 - Social Work Research: Process & Skills
c. Music 143 - Women's Chorus
d. Music 233 - Piano Ensemble
II. University Studies Course Approvals
Humanities |
# |
Course Name |
S.H. |
Rep |
Foreign
Languages |
101 |
Elementary
German I |
4 |
Ronald Mazur |
Foreign
Languages |
101 |
Elementary
French I |
4 |
Timothy Frisk |
Foreign
Languages |
101 |
Elementary
Spanish I |
4 |
Monica Revak |
Foreign
Languages |
102 |
Elementary
French II |
4 |
Timothy Frisk |
Foreign
Languages |
102 |
Elementary
Spanish II |
4 |
Monica Revak |
Foreign
Languages |
102 |
Elementary
German II |
4 |
Ronald Mazur |
Music |
109 |
Intro. To Music |
3 |
Suzanne Draayer |
Social
Science |
|
|
|
|
| Geography |
110 |
World Regional
Geography |
3 |
Jerry Gerlach |
Geography |
213 |
Cultural
Geography |
3 |
Jerry Gerlach |
Natural
Science |
|
|
|
|
| Biology |
104 |
Conservation |
3 |
Robin
Richardson |
Biology |
118 |
General Biology |
4 |
Kimberly Bates |
Biology |
203 |
Natural History |
4 |
Carol Jefferson |
Biology |
211 |
Anatomy &
Physiology I |
4 |
Dave Dapkus |
Biology |
212 |
Human Anatomy
& Physiology II |
4 |
Frances
Ragsdale |
Geoscience |
115 |
Meteorology |
4 |
Dennis
Battaglini |
Fine &
Performing Arts |
|
|
|
|
| Music |
320 |
Music for
Elementary Teachers |
3 |
Cathy Schmidt |
Music |
110 |
History of
American Jazz |
3 |
Rich MacDonald |
Music |
324 |
Recreational
Music |
2 |
Cathy Schmidt |
Music |
247 |
Woodwind
Ensemble |
1 |
James S. Hoch |
Music |
120 |
Intro. To Music
Theory |
3 |
Don Lovejoy |
Music |
233* |
Piano Ensemble |
1 |
Cathy Schmidt |
Music |
143* |
Women's Chorus |
1 |
Harry Mechell |
Music |
241 |
Symphonic Wind
Ensemble |
1 |
Don Lovejoy |
Music |
239 |
Jazz Combo |
1 |
Rich MacDonald |
Music |
244 |
Jazz Ensemble |
1 |
Rich MacDonald |
Music |
240 |
Percussion
Ensemble |
1 |
Rich MacDonald |
Science
& Social Policy |
|
|
|
|
| Psychology |
330 |
Psychology
& the Law |
3 |
Peter Miene |
Chemistry |
320 |
Environmental
Chemistry |
4 |
Mark Engen |
Global
Perspectives |
|
|
|
|
| Economics |
404 |
International
Economics |
3 |
Gabriel
Manrique |
Economics |
415 |
International
Economic Dev. |
3 |
Gabriel
Manrique |
Finance |
440 |
International
Finance |
3 |
Gabriel
Manrique |
Multicultural
Perspec |
|
|
|
|
| Geography |
225 |
Geography of
Latin America |
3 |
Jerry Gerlach |
Foreign
Languages |
201 |
Intermediate
French I |
4 |
Rosine
Tenenbaum |
Foreign
Languages |
201 |
Intermediate
German I |
4 |
Ronald Mazur |
Foreign
Languages |
201 |
Intermediate
Spanish I |
4 |
Mercedes
Juan-Saura |
Foreign
Languages |
202 |
Intermediate
French II |
4 |
Rosine
Tenenbaum |
Foreign
Languages |
202 |
Intermediate
German II |
4 |
Ronald Mazur |
Political
Science |
226 |
Politics &
Society in Africa |
3 |
Yogesh Grover |
Political
Science |
390 |
Comparative
Politics in the Third World |
3 |
Yogesh Grover |
Political
Science |
270 |
Politics &
Society in the Middle East |
3 |
Yogesh Grover |
Music |
114 |
World Music |
3 |
Cathy Schmidt |
Music |
115 |
Music of East
and Southeast Asia |
3 |
Cathy Schmidt |
Music |
116 |
Music of the
Americas |
3 |
Cathy Schmidt |
Contemp.
Citizenship |
|
|
|
|
| Accounting |
211 |
Financial
Accounting Principles |
3 |
Jim Hurley |
Motion Carried.
B. Graduate Council (Com B)
Grad Council sent the following for Faculty Senate approval:
EL789 - Writing Seminar: Specialist Field Study, Department of Educational Leadership
Course Credit Change from Two to Three.
Revision of Nurse Educator focus courses in the graduate program, including two new
courses (669, 672) and two courses (670, 671).
N669 - Nursing Education: Theory and Research [1-3
sh]
N670 - Nursing Education: Curricula and Program Design
[ 3sh]
N671 - Nursing Education-Instruction and Evaluation [2 sh]
N672 - Nursing Education-Instruction and Evaluation Practicum [1-2 sh]
Motion Carried.
C. Government Relations Committee
Darrell
Downs briefly reported on the following:
1. Everything (budget) is up in the air.
2. Contact Sen. Deanna Wiener to thank her for her support and to
convey concerns about the transfer bill to her, as well as
other Senators including the bill's sponsor, Sen. Kinkel.
- Personnel Policies and Grievance Committee
No report
E. Committee on Committees
No report
F. Negotiations/Action
Matt Hyle reported the following:
At the IFO website (www.ifo.org) one can
find the official report, the actual text of the IFO's 1st
proposal, the text of MnSCU's 1st proposal, and the IFO's economic proposal.
From 10am Thursday, March 22 through noon, Saturday, March 24, the IFO and MnSCU
negotiating teams met and exchanged language proposals. The IFO also presented its
economic package. Any economic proposal that MnSCU could offer at this time would be, in
their term, counter-productive. We should not expect any economic proposal from MnSCU
until they have a firm idea of their budget.
After the two and half days of bargaining, 8 tentative agreements (TAs) were reached.
Barring some unforeseen circumstance, the following will be included in the new contract:
1. Eligibility for phased retirement is reduced from age 55 and 15 years of service to
age 55 and ten years of service. (IFO proposal)
2. The new deadlines for phased retirement notification will be Oct. 1 for those
retiring at the end of an academic year and Jan. 15 for those retiring at the end of a
calendar year. (IFO proposal)
3. Faculty in phased retirement will be expected to perform pro rata the entire
workload of a faculty member. (IFO proposal)
4. There will be parallel language on phased retirement for faculty on annuitant
retirees. (IFO proposal)
5. Department chairs will no longer have a special evaluation schedule. (MnSCU
proposal)
6. The sunsetted language in Article 16 Section A, subd. 3 will be deleted. (MnSCU
proposal)
7. Clarifying that retrenched faculty who live within 50 miles of the border will have
their travel expenses to a job interview within MnSCU paid by MnSCU and those living more
than 50 miles are responsible for their travel expenses. (IFO proposal: technical
adjustment)
8. The tuition waiver for faculty and their dependents will be counted starting in the
1st summer session rather than the over the fiscal year. (Both sides).
G. Treasurer's Report
(NB-G)
Darrell Downs submitted the fall (1st Quarter) FY2001and Fall (2nd
Quarter) FY 2001budget reports.
P. Vance/R. Elcombe moved for approval of the submitted budget reports.
Motion Carried.
Executive Committee moved to give Kathy Schott (working 15 hr/wk) the equivalent of six
weeks of paid vacation (clarified as during the summer). This amounts to $945 total.
C. Hyman/S. Smith moved to postpone till the next Senate meeting. (To address questions
and clarify on issues of how many years would this be occurring, and what happens if we
have a different person. Maybe we should call this a Bonus.)
Motion Carried.
H. Social Committee
Bill Ng reported the following:
1. The IFO Honors Dinner Banquet will be Wednesday April 18th at the
Westfield Golf Course. Faculty retirees are: Dennis Battaglini (Physics), Don Gadow
(English), Dean Feller (Math/Stats), Kent Cowgill (English), Susan Rislove (Children
Center). Another honoree will be our IFO President, Alex Yard. There will be a Social at
4:30, free appetizers, a Cash Bar and door prizes. Dinner begins at 6:30 with program for
the honorees following.
2. Faculty Senators are encouraged to attend and should encourage colleagues to come
celebrate the many years of dedicated years of service of honorees.
3. Look for Banquet invitations in your mailboxes.
4. More advertisement to come.
VII. Old Business
- A. Assessment of Semester Length (OB-A)
The ad hoc committee on assessing changes in the semester recommends:
That the university assess the impact of potential changes in the academic calendar by
studying the questions concerning Time on Task contained in the current university-wide
assessment survey instrument. If the university proceeds with this action, the ad hoc
committee also recommends:
a. Establishment of a standing Committee on Assessment of the Academic Term
b. That the committee selects the survey questions that provides the best indicators of
Time on Task, and requests the university Assessment Office to supply the appropriate
data.
c. That the committee provides an annual report on the indications of Time on Task to
the Faculty Senate and Administration.
B. Abdel-Magid/J. Stejskal moved to approve the above.
Motion Carried.
R. Elcombe/S. Smith moved to forward to Committee on Committees (1
person
per College)
Motion Carried.
B. Calendar for 2002-2004 (OB-B)
Three Calendars:
1. Cal A: 2002-2003 classes start before Labor Day. Fall; 84 days (69 Class Days),
15 weeks including 5 holidays, 10 Faculty Dev. Days, spring (74 Class Days); 15 weeks,
5 Fac. Dev. Days.
2. Cal B: 2002-2003 classes start before Labor Day. Fall (74 Class Days), 85 Days; 15
weeks plus 5 holidays, 6 Faculty Dev. Days, Spring (74 Class Days), 83 Days; 15 weeks,
4 Fac. Dev. Days.
3. Cal C: 2002-2003 classes start after Labor Day (from Faculty Recommendation)
fall (69 Class Days) - 82 days; 14 weeks, 55 minute class periods. Commencement
late December. 8 Fac. Dev. Days Spring (70 Class Days), 86 days; 14 weeks, start after
Martin Luther King, Commencement late May. 14 Fac. Dev. Days
The All-University Calendar Committee recommended Calendar A to President Krueger.
A signed petition from eleven A2C2 representatives stating that there is a serious
concern among some departments about the adoption of the 14-week calendar. Of the three
calendars submitted to the departments for considerations, the 14-week option is not the
first choice of the undersigned A2C2 representatives and their departments. These reps and
their departments are requesting that this issue be looked at more closely before the
final calendar is selected.
P. Vance/J. Stejskal moved for Senate to re-consider the Senate's previous stance on the Calendars, which
was: Calendar C resembles closest to the Senate endorsed 14-week Semester concept.
M. Hyle/S. Barbor moved to table this until we get Robert's Rule clarification.
Motion to table defeated.
Ruling from President Yard to go with the motion with majority vote.
M. Hyle/S. Barbor moved to challenge President Yards ruling.
Motion to challenge defeated.
Back to the Vance/Stejskal motion to re-consider.
Motion to reconsider carried. (12-11).
Discussion on re-consideration of 14-week semester:
1. Going from 50 to 55 min scheduling is difficult.
2. Argument for student housing rental period was weak.
3. Less weeks for Performing Arts.
4. Less time to revise student's
projects/work.
5. Most faculty and students do not understand why we are going to the 14-week
semester.
6. Cal A does not have equal teaching days between the two semesters.
7. Stewart Shaw stated that the 10-minute-breaks between classes count toward the total
Carnegie minutes of instruction.
8. Some natural science field experience courses prefer Cal C, some don't.
9. Nursing dept. prefers 15-week semester, i.e. Cal A or Cal B.
10. Having extra non-class duty days would give WSU more money from MnSCU.
Motion on the table is to re-consider (approve or disapprove) the 14-week Semester
Concept.
Motion carried on re-approving the 14-week Semester Concept.
C. Hyman/C. Summa moved to approve Cal C.
Motion Carried.
C. Non-Classroom Days and Individual Contracts (OB-C)
A draft copy of Policy Statement on Use of Faculty Development Days came from the
administration. Implementation could result in an extra $2M allocation from MnSCU.
Proposed solution:
1) That the faculty member's individual contract more accurately reflect the use of
their time by specifically identifying the 15 non-designated class days for a specific
purpose, whether for research or for community service.
2) That individual faculty members would have the opportunity of designating these 15
days for research or for community service, or for some combination thereof.
3) That faculty and administration work together to construct wording that would
accurately reflect faculty workload on individual faculty contracts.
Discussion:
1. What about the four criteria?
M. Hyle/C. Hyman moved to forward to PP&G for comments and seek Frank Conroy's
advice.
Motion Carried.
D. Supervision of Student Teachers (See M & C Notes)
This Supervision of Student Teachers document is only specified for the
Department of Education. If other departments (other than Education) would like to get
student teacher supervision, they should appeal through the proper channels, perhaps
through PEAC or through Senate, or through Education.
President Yard was asked to find clarification on notification of student-supervisor
loads, ask for feedback from the two departments in the College of Education, and perhaps
also talk to PEAC.
E. WSU Reg. 3-14 (See M & C Notes and OB-E)
The administration forwarded more changes to Reg. 3-14, including adding PDP/PDR to
all commenting processes.
B. Ng/B. Svingen moved to forward to PP&G.
Motion Carried.
VIII. New Business
A. Draft Call for Faculty Technology Fellows Applications (NB-A)
The administration has approved the carry over of the present five faculty technology
fellows, (since they started in mid-year this year).
This initiative will be continued next year.
Need to let faculty know present Faculty Technology Fellows.
P. Miene/S. Sloan moved to approve the solicitation of Faculty Technology Fellows.
Motion Carried.
B. Draft Call for Applications for Laptop Program Director (NB-B distributed at
meeting)
A request for a nomination/application for WSU laptop director (faculty liaison) for
next year has been given to Faculty Senate. Revisions/updates of the job description have
been considered. This position resembles that of an Ombuds-person.
D. Downs/R. Elcombe moved to approve the application process but with appointment of a
search committee (faculty out-numbering administration) and with clarification of
re-assigned time.
Motion Carried.
C. Draft Personnel Decision Deadline Schedule (NB-C)
A draft copy of Personnel Decision Deadline Schedule for 2001-2002 was presented.
D. Bratt/S. Eiken moved to forward to PP&G.
Motion Carried.
D. Faculty Course Webs
Postponed.
E. Tentative Faculty Senate and A2C2 Meeting Schedule for 2001-2002
(NB-E)
B. Svingen/S. Barbor moved to approve the meeting schedules.
Motion Carried.
F. Academic Excellence Banquet (NB-F)
The IFO is co-sponsoring the Winona Chamber Academic Excellence Banquet, to be held at
WSU on Monday, April 16, 2001 at 6:30 p.m. It's recommended that the WSUFA send a
representative or two to this event.
M. Hyle/S. Sloan moved to ask President Yard to solicit faculty volunteers.
Motion Carried.
G. Faculty Mentor Program Presentation (Lucinia Barrueco) (NB-G)
Postponed.
H. Letter of Understanding from SCSU
The Executive Committee moved to instruct the WSUFA-Board reps. to strongly oppose the
Letter of Understanding from St. Cloud, which basically is an attempt to resurrect the
Specialist position. (I.e. hiring multi-year slave-faculty to teach English intro
courses.)
Motion Carried. (Unanimous)
IX. Adjournment
B. Ng/M. Engen moved to adjourn at 5:50 p.m.
Motion Carried.
Respectfully submitted,
Bill Ng.
|