WSU FACULTY SENATE MEETING
September 17, 2001

Senators Present: Sara Barbor, Danning Bloom, Matt Bosworth, David Bratt, Narayan Debnath, Darrell Downs, Mark Engen, Pat Ferden, Joe Jackson, Mary Kesler, Cindy Killion, Daniel Lintin, Peter Miene, Bill Ng, Christine Pilon-Kacir (in Rochester), Susanne Smith, Jo Stejskal, Cathy Summa, Bruce Svingen, Paul Vance, Kerry Williams, Alex Yard.

Senators Absent: Marianna Byman, Matthew Hyle, Colette Hyman, Frances Ragsdale,

Others Present: Joe Mount, Kelly Herold, Matt Bartlett, Lyndsey Hafner, Ann Nolin, Kristen Miller, Hui-Min Chin, Dean Johnson, Barbara Boseker, Jim Reineke, Kerry Fine.

 

I. Call to Order
David Bratt called the meeting to order at 3:00 p.m.

II. Approval of minutes of 8/27/01
D. Lintin/C. Summa moved to approve minutes of August 27th as written.
Motion Carried.

 

III. Agenda Additions and Approval:
ADD:

Com-G: Treasurer's report
NB-G: $400
NB-H: Post Retirement Health Care Savings Plan
NB-I: Professional Issues (Foster)
NB-J: Kerry Fine

bulletNote: NB-B: revised to start at 4 p.m.

C. Killion/S. Barbor moved to approve agenda additions.
Motion Carried.

Inter-session: Kelly Herold announced that a series of speakers, including Ted Kennedy Jr. will be on campus. He passed around a list of dates to give faculty advanced notice. The lists included time of visitation and faculty Senators have been given advanced sign-up privileges.

 

IV. President's Report
D. Bratt noted he received thanks from Sue Ann Mullen for the IFO flowers she received for her father's passing.

President's Report

David Bratt
9/17/01

1. I sent out an email to department chairs and program directors, giving some detail about two issues on our agenda that seemed to have particular pertinence to the operations of academic programs. I plan to continue sending these sorts of notices if I can.

2. The FA sent a memorial in the name of Connie Donovan, wife of John Donovan.

3. Mary Kesler, Bruce Svingen, and I attended an IFO Board meeting last week Thursday and Friday. Among the nuggets we collected were:

Acronym of the week: Tech College and Community College faculty have merged their unions. The new one is called Minnesota State College Faculty, MSCF, pronounced 'Mischief.'

bulletThe IFO Salary Equity Committee continues to struggle to get their job done. They and reps from MnSCU have assembled 96-97 data, but the System's higher-ups insist that all the data be verified (e.g., graveyards visited to confirm that someone really is dead?) before the package is submitted to a consultant for analysis.
bulletThe Board established a Liaison/Coordinator for Retired Faculty and appointed Sally Sloan to the position.
bulletThere are 18 grievances at Step 3 (down from a much higher number this summer). 10 are from SCSU.
bullet15% of the faculty at the state universities are on fixed-term contracts (WSU's figure is 16%). The new chancellor comes from a system that had a cap of 7% fixed-term.
bulletThe chancellor suggested that WSU go off campus to hold its presidential installation ceremony so that he wouldn't have to cross a picket line to attend.
bulletReports from other campus FA presidents:

Campuses reported a variety of forums, vigils, and teach-ins in response to last week's events.

                    The new president at SWSU reversed a series of retrenchments announced by his predecessor.

The FA President at Mankato predicts that the major bone of contention this year will be faculty parking.

Moorhead has just discovered a $1.2 million shortfall, due to some sort of computational or accounting error.

Additional (reported during Senate meeting):

1. Picket signs: If IFO members carry a picket sign, make sure it doesn't say, "I am on Strike..." This sign would be illegal for IFO members to carry.

2. Fed W-S students can't be hired/reassigned to do strikers' jobs. This does not apply to State W-S workers. IFO has stated strong language regarding administrative compliance of NOT hiring scabs.

3. Notes on: Poor Search results from last year, AFSCME Health chart listing difference between current support level, offer by MnSCU/Doer, and what's being asked for by AFSCME, Enrollment numbers.

D. Lintin/P. Vance moved to invite administrators (to come to Faculty Senate) to discuss the large student increase and the impact on budget, including impact on class sizes and service to students, and what faculty is giving up.

Motion Carried.

4. At 3 p.m. next Monday (9/24), IFO exec's will meet with NCA team instead of the scheduled M&C meeting. The Meet and Confer meeting will take place afterwards at 4 p.m.

 

V. Review of Meet and Confer notes from 9/10/01
Notes were included in the packet.

Correction:

#10: one from psychology (instead of one from biology twice).

K. Williams stated his disagreement with the administration's statement "Having one additional IFO from each of Biology and Psych. would improve the chance of having a rep from each department at every meeting."

#12: K. Williams stated that he requested previously that the changes in flags and courses could be placed on the web.

He further noted this issue will be taken up at A2C2.

Notes received by Senate.

 

VI. Committee Reports

A. A2C2 (and statewide Academic Affairs)
No report.
D. Downs/B. Svingen moved to name Alex Yard as rep. on Statewide Academic Affairs.
Motion Carried.

Alex noted that high priority items: Transfer agreement, MN Teacher Certification/Testing procedures.

B. Graduate Council
No Report.

C. Government Relations (statewide and local)
Darrell Downs briefly reported the following:

* The committee met with Michael Tillman, Staff Director of the State Board of Teaching, and IFO Academic Affairs Committee members, Deborah Japp and Alex Yard, for an explanation of proposed rules on alternative teacher licensing.

* The committee, in conjunction with the IFO Board and Academic Affairs Committee heard a presentation from Alan Johnson on MnSCU bonding priorities.

* The committee recommended a number of political contributions to the IFO Lobby Fund (for selected Republican and DFL legislators).

* The committee will meet in mid November to complete its recommendations for new IFO legislative goals.

D. Personnel Policies and Grievance
The following are action items from PP&G:

1. Student Teacher Supervision Loads (OB-A from 5/2/01)

The memo from Dean Anderson to President Krueger is not clear, especially the third paragraph which describes the process of determining loads. The committee specifically

a). desires clarification of the chronology of the process discussed (i.e., a clear listing of who is doing what and in what order)
and
b). expresses concern regarding the process by which this proposed solution was created. Committee members believed, following Meet & Confer, that the department would come up with this process.

M/S Hyle/Smith, 7-0
Go back to Meet and confer to ask for these clarifications.
Motion Carried.

2. Regulation 3-14 (NB-B)

The committee has the following questions/concerns regarding Regulation 3-14 as written:

a). NTT and fixed-term faculty are not mentioned. Is this an oversight, or is an additional regulation going to be written?
b). Point 3 seems to combine the tenure and promotion decisions
c). Point 8 only addresses faculty reporting on an annual basis

M/S Hyle/Smith, 7-0

PP&G moved to take to Meet and Confer for clarifications.
Motion Carried.

3. Regulation 3-15 (or 3-26?) (NB-C)

Following discussion, the committee decided that a meeting between VPAA Richardson (and any other appropriate administrator) and PP&G may be the most efficient way to proceed on this regulation. Recommend asking for a meeting at Meet & Confer.

M/S Hyle/Ng, 8-0
PP&G moved to ask for clarifications at Meet and Confer and ask for the aforementioned meeting.
Motion Carried.

E. Committee on Committees (in conjunction with NB items C and D)

The Committee on Committees recommended that the following members be appointed to the WINGS Task Force:

Dennis Pack - Mass Comm
Gail Grimm - HHP
Jim Reineke - Education

Motion Carried.

 

F. Action Committee

The committee will be meeting this Friday at 10 a.m. to discuss what to accomplish at a rally (if strike). When and where will be discussed also. Faculty Senators were invited to this meeting.

 

G. Treasurer

Com-G was presented at the Senate meeting.
B. Svingen/M. Kesler moved to approve last year's budget report.
Motion Carried.

Senate moved to approve the FY02 proposed budget.
Motion Carried.

 

VII. Old Business

A. Student Teacher Supervision Load Fall 2001

As requested by FA Senate, the administration provided the information during the 9/10 Meet and Confer meeting. Document titled "Student teacher supervisor loads for Fall 2001" dated September 8, 2001, (originator Carol Anderson) was attached in the packet as OB-A.

The student teacher supervision loads for Spring 2001 will be coming later.

Comments by Barbara Boseker relative to Senators comments/questions.

1. Sp. Ed. voted to support 18 cr.1 teacher again this year. Gone around and around with Dean of Education. She previously agreed on this full load status. Sp. Ed. does not agree with how Dean of Education is allocating student teacher loads. B. Boseker stated that NCATE requires the 18 cr. 1 teacher load for accreditation.

2. Sp. Ed. needs are different from that of Ed since Sp. Ed. supervisor has to visit many more different sites than Ed.

A. Yard/B. Svingen moved to refer this matter to PP&G and that the NCA documents be forwarded to PP&G.
Motion Carried.

B. AA/HR Office Assessment

The administration provided a single (draft) copy at the 9/10 Meet and Confer meeting. VP-Richardson noted the results done with the Covey Foundation and was quite costly. This is to be viewed as an assessment tool, not evaluative. This should give the campus a start on how the campus view the AA/HR office.

A final copy will be forthcoming.

Faculty Senators who would like a copy should e-mail D. Bratt.

C. Fixed Term and Adjunct Faculty list 2000-2001

A list of Fixed Term for FY2001 was enclosed in the Senate packet.

Senate Comments:

1. Senators noted that the list is not complete.

S. Smith/A. Yard moved to ask for a complete list at next Meet and Confer.
Motion Carried.

Adjunct list will be forthcoming.

D. Additional Duties of Administrators Report (Revised)

Senate deferred action on the Report Describing Additional Duties Assigned to Administrators at Various Times, provided last Spring, because a revised version of the Report had not yet arrived.

D. Bratt requested that the administration provide a revised version of the Report, prior to the next Senate meeting, if possible. Tess Kruger requests for some clarification. She was not present at the Meet and Confer meeting when FA-exec's asked the questions. Tess Kruger appeared to have been given enough clarification during this meeting to provide a revised version of the Report.

The administrators will provide a revised copy at the next Meet and Confer.

No report received at time of this Senate meeting. Will ask at next Meet and Confer again!

VIII. New Business

A. NCA-Exec Committee Meeting and time of 9/24 Meet and Confer

The Sep. 24 Meet and Confer will occur during the NCA Visit dates. The NCA team would like to visit with the FA-Senate at ~3 p.m. D. Bratt requests that the 9/24 Meet and Confer be scheduled at a later time on that date? The administration proposed ~4 p.m.

B. 'E-Learning Center' Proposal

The administration proposed that WSU build (and enhance) an environment that focuses on technology application for faculty. A document titled "WSU E-Learning Center " was given to FA-exec's. This center could begin this year and serves as a pilot year. This represents a best shot at beginning an E-learning environment for faculty development. The E-learning Center would be supervised by an E-Learning Director, who would report to Assoc.VP Clements. The E-Learning Director is a new position. An E-Learning Advisory Team is being proposed to be composed of: a Dean's rep, AUTC rep, FATECH rep, Rochester rep, Cont. Ed./Outreach rep, TSC rep, ITS rep, E-Learning Center Director, and the Laptop Liaison. This team would be proposing/considering E-Learning Policies and Directions.

The administration would like to start this center as soon as possible.

Comments from 9/10 Meet and Confer meeting:

1. The E-Learning Director carries out policies drafted by the E-Learning Team.

2. Searches for positions that are not presently filled will begin as soon as possible. Due to the soon-to-be-expired contract, the MAC-focused E-Learning Center Analyst position will be opened for a search soon.

3. No real new money, just combined and shifted internally. For example, The E-Learning Director position, a MSUAASF level-E position, will be funded from existing unfilled positions from IT and ACEED).

4. The E-Learning Instructional Designer (used to be available only to College of Nursing and Health Sciences) will now be available to the university.

5. This document is a working draft/document. Suggestions are welcome.

D. Bratt's summary:

The proposal aims to gather under one functional umbrella, and primarily in one physical location (the library), most or all of those pieces of computer equipment and those personnel, currently scattered around campus, that are devoted to developing faculty's expertise in classroom use of computers, use of the web in instruction, etc. It is proposed to hire a Director who would oversee the implementation of policies that would be established by a steering committee. This group would consist of faculty as well as other interested campus groups and offices.

Two documents: WSU E-Learning Center Proposal, E-Learning Director Position Description.

Senate Comments:

1. The chart implies more compartmentalization of technology, rather than putting everything under one umbrella.

2. Where is the Laptop Liaison and the FATECH Committee?

3. E-Learning Director (a MSUAASF position) cannot/should not supervise/direct faculty.

4. The proposal and org-chart are very confusing (relative to the concept of integration of technology)!

5. This proposal was developed during the summer, without any faculty input!

A. Yard/B. Svingen moved to refer to FATech committee for comments.
Motion Carried.

C. Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee Composition

IACUC is in charged of looking at research proposals involving animals.

The administration has combined the minimum requirements from agriculture and NIH. The committee requires a minimum of five members. Presently, the membership consists of one from Biology, one from Psychology, an ethicist, a vet, and G&SP Director (ex-officio). One of the members must be outside WSU.

The administration proposed that the committee memberships for faculty be increased from two faculty to four faculty (i.e. two from Biology and two from Psychology). Having one additional IFO from each of Biology and Psych would improve the chance of having a rep from each department at every meeting. Tim Dost, a Winona Clergy member, was contacted to be the ethicist. He also represents an outside-WSU member. He has agreed to be a member of the committee. The administration would like to have faculty appointments recommended to them.

A. Yard/C. Killion moved to approve to add one member to each of psych and biol., two for each biol. and psych.

Discussion surrounded why one needs to have two members, since this is not an issue in actual practice
in previous meetings.
Motion Carried.

A. Yard/D. Lintin moved to refer to Comm on Comm.
Motion Carried.

IFO (D. Bratt) should check whether 2 or 3 or 4 credits count as the IFO member unit.

D. Residential College Steering Committee Composition

The administration proposed that the Residential College Steering Committee be appointed two more members. Having more faculty members appointed on this committee would help to reflect the university-wide intent/effect of the Residential College concept.

B. Ng/A. Yard moved to approve the new composition and to refer to Comm. and Comm.
Motion Carried.

E. Convocation Opening Ceremony Proposal

The administration proposed that WSU plan for a convocation ceremony during fall orientation week. They would like the Commencement Committee to discuss and plan for this event.

Comments:

1. To include all faculty and staff, and 1st-year students.

A. Yard/S. Smith moved to inform at Meet and Confer that recommendations are to come back to Senate.
Motion Carried.

F. Service Day Committee

The administration proposed that we have a Service Day in the springtime. A document was given to the FA exec's. This document is a letter addressed to all constituencies. It speaks to the importance of service to the community. It calls for the establishing of the Community Service Planning Committee composed of:

5 IFO
5 students
2 MSUAASF
2 Council 6
1 Coalition
1 Council of Administrators

This committee is in charged of coordinating the activities of a service day, a day during the academic year in which members of the WSU students, faculty and staff would work on a variety of service projects. The day will conclude with a campus-wide celebration to show appreciation for the volunteers.

FA Senate Comments:

M. Bosworth/D. Bloom moved to accept with the condition that the service day NOT take away a teaching day, should come at expense of a faculty development day (i.e. non-teaching duty day).
Motion Carried.

B. Svingen/S. Smith moved to refer to Comm. on Comm.
Motion Carried.

G. $400

Upon strike action by AFSCME and MAPE, State IFO proposed to give $400 (200 by local IFO and 200 by state IFO).

D. Downs/B. Svingen moved to approve the matching donation.
Motion Carried.

H. Post Retirement Health Care Savings Plan

Information provided at Senate regarding Post Retirement Health Care Savings Plan drafted by the MN State Retirement System (dated 8/2/01). Senators were briefed by D. Bratt on specific features. Jim Pehler and Russ Stanton will be coming around campuses. FYI only. This document will be e-send to IFO members.

I. Professional Issues (Foster)

Postponed until the next Senate Meeting.

J. Kerry Fine

Discussion of Senate members with Kerry Fine on issues related to services provided on campus.

IX. Adjournment

B. Barbor/M. Engen moved to adjourn at 5:00 p.m.

Motion Carried.

 

Respectfully submitted,
Bill Ng.