In my mass communication theory class on March 21 we discussed the proposed smoking ban in Minnesota and how to persuade someone to be against it.
We eventually discussed battling freedoms as a choice for or against it, and I came to understand my reasons to support it.
I can respect the freedom to smoke, but what I can’t respect is a freedom that harms others.
Due to many different forms of cancer in my family, I know my chances are much higher to develop it. One grandpa died of lung cancer, the other of skin and bone cancer. My uncle was recently diagnosed with colon cancer and is now undergoing chemotherapy.
We have a way of restricting freedoms that harm other in the U.S.
All citizens, thanks to the second amendment, have the right to bear arms. However, the second this privilege is abused it is lost. The same precedent should be applied to smoking.
Statistics and studies have shown secondhand smoke to be debilitating. I’m sure many who don’t smoke aren’t thrilled at the prospect of developing lung cancer for the sake of someone else’s freedom.
So here is a question I pose to you. Why is such a damaging habit that is proven to have negative health effects, not only for those who actively consume it but those who passively consume it, still legal?
My guess would be that the cigarette industry has become too large a market and can’t be easily dismantled.
Speaking of smoking policies, there is one on campus directing people to stand a minimum of 25 feet away from buildings while smoking. Most people here can attest that unless a person is walking and smoking, most standing smokers are usually within 25 feet.
Take, for instance, the gap between Phelps and Somsen Halls. This gap must be near 50 feet, which means smoking anywhere between the two is within the required minimum distance of one or the other. People smoke there often, which is particularly annoying when exiting the building.
Students would have less a problem with smoking if those who did respected those who didn’t by following rules that should be common courtesy.

Reach Paul Solberg at PTSolber3844@winona.edu